MT5 fill policy is one of the settings to check when you compare broker accounts. It describes how an order handles the requested volume. It does not tell you whether a broker is trustworthy, whether a strategy will work or what a future trade will cost.
By Best Forex Brokers Editorial. This guide is for readers comparing MT5 account functions, rather than looking for a trading signal. It uses the platform developer’s documentation and offers a worksheet you can use when asking a broker about its settings.
Risk disclaimer: This is not financial advice or investment advice. Leveraged forex and CFDs can cause substantial losses. Product availability, account rules and legal protections depend on your jurisdiction and contracting entity.
What MT5 fill policy controls
MetaQuotes distinguishes three volume-handling policies. Fill or Kill, commonly called FOK, requires the requested volume to be filled in full or the order is not executed. Immediate or Cancel, called IOC, permits the available portion to fill and cancels the remainder. Under Return, a remaining portion can stay in processing rather than being canceled. The supported choices depend on the execution mode and instrument. See the developer’s official order-filling documentation for its definitions and restrictions.
A useful research question is therefore narrow: what policy does this account support for this symbol and order type? Avoid treating the answer as a universal feature of every account carrying the same broker logo. Ask for the relevant account documentation if you cannot find the setting.
Separate quantity from price
Start your comparison with two columns: volume handling and price handling. In the first, record whether partial execution is permitted and what happens to any unfilled quantity. In the second, record the broker’s explanation of pricing, execution and order restrictions.
Keeping those columns separate makes a sales answer easier to evaluate. A statement about filling all the requested quantity does not, by itself, answer your questions about spread, commission or the price of an eventual execution. Likewise, a screenshot of a quote does not explain how remaining order volume is treated.
An illustrative reading exercise
Imagine that you are examining a hypothetical order for ten units, while a document discusses the availability of six units. This is a simplified quantity example, not a forex contract-size recommendation or a prediction of real market liquidity.
Using the definitions above, ask three questions: must all ten be available together; can six be executed while four are canceled; or can an unfilled remainder stay under the applicable policy? Write each answer beside the corresponding policy name. Then check whether that policy is actually supported in the account you are researching.
The exercise is deliberately about interpreting a rule. It does not establish that an order will execute, that a particular quantity is appropriate or that choosing one policy reduces trading losses.
Questions for the broker
- Which filling policies are available for the instrument and account type?
- Where is the current execution-policy document?
- What happens if a requested policy is unsupported?
- How are partial executions shown in order history?
- Does the demo configuration match the account being considered?
Ask for a written answer that identifies the account type and policy version. Save the date alongside the response. If two documents appear inconsistent, request clarification before interpreting either one as the final answer. A support conversation should add evidence, not replace the original policy.
Build a comparison row
Your row can contain the broker’s legal entity, account label, instrument, execution mode, available filling policy, document link and date checked. Add a separate unresolved-questions column. This keeps missing information visible instead of converting it into a favorable score.
Use our broker review methodology to understand the broader categories considered in a review. This article adds an operational check; it does not assign a broker ranking or claim that we tested a particular account.
A worksheet for checking MT5 fill policy
Use a small comparison sheet with separate rows for each account and instrument. Write the source beside every answer. For example, a platform screenshot can show the menu options you saw, while a policy document can explain the rules. Neither one alone proves that all the options apply to every order you might submit.
Give the worksheet three answer states: confirmed, unclear and not applicable. Reserve confirmed for a statement supported by the relevant document or a written account-specific response. Use unclear when you have only a promotional phrase, an old screenshot or an answer about a different account. Use not applicable only after understanding why the setting does not apply.
| Field | What to record | Question if missing |
|---|---|---|
| Account identity | Legal entity, account label and server | Which exact account does this policy cover? |
| Instrument | Full symbol and contract description | Does the answer cover this instrument? |
| Order request | Order type and filling-policy option | Which combinations are supported? |
| Unfilled quantity | Cancel or further processing | Where can I see its final state? |
| Evidence | Document link, version and date | Is a newer policy available? |
How to read a support reply
Suppose a hypothetical reply says, “We offer fast execution on MT5.” That sentence does not answer whether the account accepts IOC for your chosen order type. A better follow-up is: “Please identify the supported filling policy and the section of your execution document that covers this symbol.” This request narrows the discussion without making accusations or assuming a problem exists.
Now imagine a second reply saying that a feature exists in the demo environment. Ask whether the same rule applies to the intended live account and whether the broker documents any differences. Treat the answer as account research. Do not turn a demo observation into a claim about live performance or infer that a favorable result will repeat.
Record observations without rating the broker
When taking notes, describe what you saw rather than what you hope it means. “The menu displayed IOC on this demo account on this date” is a limited observation. “This broker always fills orders fairly” is a much broader conclusion that the menu cannot establish. Keep those two kinds of statement separate.
If you already have an order-history record to interpret, save the request identifier, requested quantity, executed quantity and final state. Remove account numbers and personal details before sharing a screenshot publicly. Ask the broker to explain any discrepancy against its own policy; this guide does not determine whether a particular execution complied with an agreement.
Common questions
Is FOK better than IOC?
There is no universal ranking in this article. The policies describe different handling of unfilled quantity. Start with the account’s supported combinations and your need to understand the rule. Do not choose a broker because one acronym sounds more protective.
Does Return apply to every order?
No. The developer’s documentation restricts Return by order type and execution mode. Read that combination, rather than assuming a general platform menu proves availability. Ask the broker which rule applies to the particular request you are examining.
Does a canceled remainder remove trading risk?
No. A volume-handling rule does not eliminate the financial risk of any executed position. Keep the explanation of order processing separate from a decision about whether to trade at all.
Before relying on a platform label
A familiar interface is only part of the research. Check the contracting firm, its current authorization, fee schedule and risk disclosures separately. Do not infer that software availability proves regulatory status or account protection. Document the evidence for each conclusion.
Editorial disclosure: Best Forex Brokers may earn commissions from qualifying referral links elsewhere on this site. This guide contains no broker referral recommendation, and platform references are informational. No firsthand test, guaranteed execution or trading outcome is claimed.